Council goes forward with sewer project
October 2, 2008 · Updated 2:37 PM
CARNATION The city of Carnation is one step closer to building
a sewer collection system and waste-water treatment plant after City
Council members voiced their unanimous approval to create a final draft of
the project's plan. The council is expected to vote on the final draft at its Sept.
For the past year the city has worked on preparing a proposal
that would bring sewers to residents and businesses. This summer, an
engineering firm hired by the city, American Engineering Corp. of Redmond,
submitted a plan that called for the collection system and treatment plant
to be built in phases. The initial phase of construction would cost $6.2
million, and subsequent phases could cost an additional $10.45 million over
Many people have repeatedly stated the need for such a system,
but some residents who have attended public workshops, forums and
hearings have been equally opposed to the proposed project.
City Councilman Stuart Lisk said the potential for current septic
systems failing far outweighs the cost of the project.
"For me, there are too many at-risk issues, and as a representative of
the city, I bear part of that burden," he said.
"There are too many people at risk with the age of the septic systems
and the size of the lots."
Councilwoman Yvonne Funder- burg agreed that with the
possibility of septic systems failing in the
future, a final draft of the project should be drawn up.
"For the benefit of the town, we need to go forward with it," she
said. " Hopefully we can go forward and find something that everybody can
be happy with."
Laurie Clinton, a member of the Sewer Advisory Committee, said in
an interview that now is the time to build a sewer system.
"This is no longer a whim This is a dire necessity," she said.
However, resident G. Miller-St. Germain, said the city is using
those potential problems as a pretext to grow the city.
"This is all about growth. This isn't about health," she said.
But Clinton said concerns about growth could be addressed by the city.
"It can be controlled, and that is up to the citizens," she said. "We
have a say in what happens. We have a good comprehensive plan.
"We can assure them we are not going to be a Duvall."
In an interview, former Mayor Dave Hunter, who also spoke at
the City Council meeting, said the city could face worse problems if a
sewer system isn't installed in the near future.
"If we don't take responsibility and do something, then we're
going to have a problem, (and) then the county, state and feds are going
to come in and do it for us," he said. And as for growth, Hunter said the
Growth Management Area for Duvall was much larger.
"(Growth is) pretty well maxed out going up the Tolt River."
Many of those attending the City Council meeting weren't happy
with the council's vote. Some said that residents don't have enough money to
pay for being connected to a sewer system, as well as paying the monthly
fee estimated at $51 to use the system.
Tom Cortade, who collected 26 signatures on a petition that asked
the City Council to let residents vote on the issue, told council members,
"Your decision will have a dramatic effect on this town for years to come."
Because of the phased-in approach of the plan, the downtown
business district and surrounding area would be the first to be connected to the
sewer system. But several people have said the city's poorest residents live in
that area, and they would be the most affected by a decision to build sewers.
Hunter said by building a sewer system now, the city could apply
for money to help those people. State and federal funds that could be used
to offset what residents would have to pay to be connected to the sewer
system are based on data collected in the 1990 census, he said. He added that
if the city waits until next year, after the 2000 census is adopted, the city
might not qualify for low-income funding.
"Carnation, based on the 1990 census, had a per-capita income
of $33,000 per household," Hunter said. "That puts you in a
qualification bracket for such things as sewers."
Clinton said the Sewer Advisory Committee believes the city could
receive additional funding to pay for a sewer system.
"We think there's great promise for additional grants above and
beyond those that we would be eligible for.
"So many cities have been sewered, there's so much money
Throughout this process, several residents have asked the city to put
the issue to a vote. Michael Finley of Carnation said of the people he's
talked to, they all want a sewer collection system and wastewater treatment
plant placed on a ballot.
"I haven't talked to one person that doesn't want a vote," he said.
Finley added that he wants to vote, too, saying, "That's just as important to me
as to whether or not we get it."
The City Council has not decided whether to let residents vote.
However, at the meeting, councilmembers were given a list of recommendations by
the Sewer Advisory Committee, one of which stated: "The decision to put
a sewer facility to a vote of the people rests with the council. It falls
upon them to determine what is in the best interest for the long-term benefit of
Other recommendations made by the committee include:
Exploring the feasibility adding reuse operations to the
wastewater treatment plant.
Including the Regal Glen subdivision in Phase 1 of sewer
Continue pursuing grants and other funding for the project,
especially for low-income households and seniors, as well as seeking
funding through the federal Endangered Species Act or the Clean Water Act.
Conducting further study to see if the monthly sewer fee can be